Controversial Immigration Proposal by Former President Donald Trump

In a bid for re-election in November 2024, former President Donald Trump has unveiled a contentious immigration proposal that has raised concerns among lawyers and immigrant rights organizations in the United States.

The plan, dubbed the “zero tolerance” policy, includes measures such as the construction of internment camps for processing and deporting foreigners, the arrest of long-term undocumented immigrants, and increased restrictions on legal immigration, including asylum.

Lawyers’ Response

The American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) has strongly criticized Trump’s proposed immigration plan, labeling it as “destructive” and expressing alarm at the potential consequences.

Ben Johnson, the executive director of AILA, condemned the campaign’s attack on immigrants and immigration, warning that it could lead to the era of internment camps, ideological purity tests, and mass deportations.

He also highlighted the unprecedented attack on the 14th Amendment of the Constitution, which would create a permanent subclass of non-citizens.

Activists’ Concerns

Activists from pro-immigrant organizations have also voiced their opposition to Trump’s immigration strategy. Vanessa Cárdenas, the executive director of America’s Voice, described the proposed plan as a threat to democracy and detrimental to immigrant communities.

She argued that Trump’s rhetoric and policies aimed to undermine democracy and redefine the nation’s identity. Matt Barreto, a pollster working with Democratic-affiliated groups, characterized the plan as extreme and draconian, diverging from the preferences expressed by the majority of Americans in favor of legal immigration and providing legal status to some undocumented immigrants.

Details of Trump’s Plan

Trump’s immigration proposal for a potential second term includes various measures aimed at cracking down on undocumented immigrants in the country. These measures encompass:

  • Reductions in Immigration: Trump’s plan would declare undocumented immigration a threat to national and public security.
  • Mass Arrests and Deportations: The proposal entails the location, arrest, and deportation of all undocumented foreigners in the country.
  • Massive Internment Centers: Trump’s strategy involves the establishment of large-scale internment camps for detaining foreigners.
  • Accelerated Deportation Proceedings: The plan advocates for expedited deportation hearings.
  • Restrictions on Entry: The proposal aims to impose new limitations on citizens from Muslim-majority countries and revoke visas for foreign students participating in certain protests.
  • Border Wall Construction: Trump intends to resume the construction of the border wall.
  • Reinstatement of Programs: Trump’s plan includes the restoration of the Title 42 expulsion policy, the reinstatement of the Migrant Protection Protocols (MPP) for asylum seekers, and the cancellation of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) programs.
  • Restrictions on Asylum: The proposal seeks to further restrict the policy on granting asylum.
  • Visa Program Changes: Trump plans to tighten visa programs and increase requirements for visa issuance at consulates and embassies.
  • Elimination of Humanitarian Programs: The plan proposes the elimination of existing humanitarian programs.
  • Birthright Citizenship: Trump intends to eliminate birthright citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants by amending the 14th Amendment.


Former President Donald Trump’s immigration proposal has sparked controversy and concern among lawyers, immigrant rights organizations, and activists.

Critics argue that the plan would lead to the establishment of internment camps, mass deportations, and the erosion of democratic values. While the proposal addresses border security concerns, its harsh measures and disregard for due process have drawn widespread condemnation.

As the political landscape continues to evolve, it remains to be seen how immigration policies will shape the future of the United States.